Is Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover Worth Giving a Try?

Do this product does justice to the price tag? Are the ingredients safe enough? Find out all the answers here.

Posted on | Last Updated

Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover Review

Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover: Review with Ingredient Analysis

Skin Type: Normal to Dry

As a cosmetic enthusiast, I always try to put down reviews as soon as I am done with testing products. In short, I am pretty serious as a blogger.

But, still, in 1 out of 100 cases, one product is always left out. And, this time, while decluttering my shelf, I found out that I am yet to talk about Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover.

I bought this makeup remover a while back. The primary interest was to try out at least one Physicians Formula product. And, guess what! This is the only product that could fit my budget. ­čśŤ

I used it a lot and it is almost over. But, does it mean that I loved the product? Well! Let’s find out the answer along with a detailed ingredient analysis.

Basic Information about Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

Price: INR 499
Shelf Life: 2 years
Buy From: Amazon

Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

What Does the Brand Claim about Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover?

Get ready for a nourishing and ophthalmologist tested eye makeup remover. Enriched with coconut milk, this formula is apt enough to wipe off all the traces of greasy residue form your eye area.

Give your eye area a delicate and silky-smooth touch. No more stinging or crying; removing eye makeup had never been so easy.

Ingredient Analysis of Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

Ingredient Analysis of Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

No review is complete without ingredient analysis. This is exactly what I and my team believe in Cosmetics Arena. Physicians Formula makeup remover is formulated with a bunch of ingredients. Are these ingredients safe? It’s time to find out that.


The base for any liquid or cream-based product


It is a moderately safe skin conditioning agent.


Another safe skin conditioning agent that is widely used in personal care products.


This component helps to increase the viscosity of a cosmetic.


Just like the previous component, this chemical agent works as a viscosity controller.


Indeed, coconut milk is the best natural emollient ever.

7. PEG-20

It is a moderately safe humectant and solvent.


This organic alcohol works great as a skin conditioning agent and also as a solvent.


This synthetic polymer is rated as ‘safe’. It functions as a stabilizer and also as a texture enhancer in cosmetics.


It is another widely used preservative that is a bit weak. This component also works as a skin conditioning agent.


One of the most widely used preservatives it is.


Well! Polyisobutene is primarily used as a film former. It also works as a viscosity controller.


It is actually a chelating agent. Chelating agents help to decrease the metals present in a cosmetic.


Well! I agree that this emulsifying agent is not much popular. But, fortunately, it is rated as ‘safe’.


The fermented liquid works as a natural preservative. And honestly, I loved how the brand has pushed it wisely into the formulation.


This emulsifying agent is rated as ‘safe’ by EWG. Indeed, that’s great!

Overall, most of the ingredients are safe and placed appropriately in the ingredient list. If ingredients are concerned, then I am quite happy with this makeup remover.

Unnecessarily, the fragrance is not added here. And thus, this remover is safe for people with the most sensitive skin types.

So, I would like to rate the ingredients of Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover 4.8 out of 5. But, what about the performance? Keep on reading to know the answer.

Packaging, Texture, and Aroma

The makeup remover comes in a usual plastic bottle. The cap is a flip flop one.

But, guess what! The tiny hole is not enough to squeeze out the thick cream.

So, every time, I open the cap and squeeze out the product with multiple strokes. Phew! A lot of work for sure.

Talking about the texture, it is quite creamy. In fact, the cream is pretty thick.

There is hardly any aroma as the brand claimed. The faint hint of coconut milk is all you have got here. Personally, I love this thing the most about this product.

Fragrance-free products are always my top preference.

My Experience with Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

Well! I bought the remover in January this year. As I said earlier, trying out the brand was the sole idea behind this purchase.

I usually draw a thick line on my eyelids or on my waterline with my favourite Plum Natur Studio Kajal.

Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover Texture

The colour payoff by Plum Kajal is absolutely brilliant. And thus, without a good remover, it is not easy to remove it.

But guess what, Physicians Formula Makeup Remover did absolute justice. It wiped off all the black traces in one swipe only!

The performance was quite satisfactory.

But, what I did not like is the ‘creamy’ feel afterwards. One needs a mild face wash to wash off that. Indeed, the product is meant for people with dry skin. Yet, the heaviness can be felt.

Well! This is not the case with Micellar Waters. And, probably it is one of the biggest reasons that I love Micellar Water.

Removing Makeup witrh Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

The makeup remover does not irritate my eyes which is quite an appreciable thing. Altogether the makeup remover does a pretty convincing job. In fact, I found that it can also remove lipstick stains with swiping two or three times only. Isn’t it awesome?

But, a few problems are still there. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of this eye makeup remover.

Pros of Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

  • Most of the ingredients are safe
  • Tested by Ophthalmologist
  • Fragrance-free
  • Sturdy packaging
  • The creamy texture is good for normal to dry skin
  • It can remove all traces of eye makeup

It would be wrong to call it a coconut milk based makeup remover. As the primary component is Mineral Oil here which itself is pretty effective as a makeup remover.

Cons of Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

  • It is impossible to squeeze out the product without opening the cap; in fact, multiple strokes are needed.
  • The creaminess feels heavy after swiping off the makeup; face wash is necessary
  • Pretty pricey in comparison to the quantity; the market is filled with better products

Well! That’s all for today. I hope you like this honest review. Don’t forget to share this article with your friends and family. Check and follow us on Instagram too for more such interesting stuff. Take care.

My Take on Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover

Is It Worth Giving a Shot?

Undoubtedly, it does a pretty good job in removing both eye and lip makeup. But, apart from that, it is a fail.
Illogical packaging and hefty price tag are two of the major reasons behind the failure.
Altogether, if you are a fan of Physicians Formula or looking for safe eye makeup remover, then you can give it a shot. Otherwise, I would never recommend Physicians Formula Coconut Milk Eye Makeup Remover.


Related Stories

Plum Candy Melts Vegan Lip Balm Review with Ingredient Analysis

Plum candy melts vegan lip balms

So, are the cute balms really good? Is the price justifiable? What about the goodness of the ingredients? Well! Let's check out all the answers here.